Am I Dreaming?

Once in the kitchen you feel like you need something to eat. Eating helps calm you down, so you open the fridge. Inside are the normal everyday items like milk, cheese, various jams and spreads, eggs... blah blah blah etcetera etcetera. You decide there isn't anything in the fridge you want so you go looking in the freezer for ice cream considering it is extremely hot.
You open the freezer and find that the only thing in there is ICE CREAM! Yum! You grab the ice cream out and open the box...
Out of the box comes...

You have 2 choices: