The Drakes of Heaven and Earth.

NinjaHound13: Attention all fellow Gruvia fans!
Options 2-5 will be for you guys to submit your takes on the Gray and Juvia Masquerade scenarios. But I will be expanding them to have all five options open for all four choices

Some rules:

They can't say their actual names(Though you can change them if you want to something else), nor take off their masks. Yes. Even Gray cannot take off his mask. He can take off everything else though.

I'm also more interested in seeing Juvia portrayed in a more calm and level-headed demeanor. They aren't supposed to officially meet until the Phantom Lord Arc after all.

With that being said, I'm retconning Juvia's obsessive attraction to have a better backstory. While Gray and Juvia were inside the Grimm Heights, interacting with each other, Clayton and Victoria were outside, noticing the usual rain Juvia's presence brings forth, dwindle down to nothing, until they see the night sky. They're initially caught in the beauty of a solar wind shining through the night sky, until they remember that Juvia is in the party. Having Clay rush back inside to see what could have caused these changes(because he's been drinking, and can't use his extra senses), only for someone or something to get in between Gray and Juvia before Clay could find out. Victoria would then return inside to inform Clayton that the rainstorms returned, and have Clay report no findings.
Before Juvia and the other Phantom Lord wizards leave, Victoria informs Juvia of her witness to the rainstorms being cleared. Juvia being astonished, wondering back to what could have caused it, then remembering her interactions with you know who. Victoria then tells Juvia that the man must be the one to open her heart and clear the gloomy rain clouds from her life. When she sees the skies following her defeat by Gray, she then realises that Gray is the teru-teru bōzu doll the world has put into her life. Thus her obsession begins.