Verisimilivirate

You try to think of some way to get this guy to give up some food, possibly a change of clothes (you've had about enough of this loincloth), some local currency, and lodging for the night. Without using your powers, you decide to perhaps attempt to use pantomime to portray the fact that you are in need and trust in this man's grass-roots generosity.

"Bloo-dah peesahn," he responds to your mimed pleas with pompous disdain and stretches out his right hand toward you. Could he be extending a courteous hand to you? Pointing the way to a comfy shelter for the night, perhaps?

No! He blasts you to kingdom come with a searing blue bolt of lightning! Fortunately for you, you become a returner headed back to Earth. Unfortunately for you, Fred was displeased with your lack of use of your powers while on Blue and makes a deal with God on your way back to Earth. You arrive as what you were, but become a master martial arts teacher who ironically never gets in a single fight his entire pointless life. So there.
End Of Story