Gwen's Dating Sim

You go with Nyx to the docks to try and get a boat to take you to the orc island which is where you need to go.

You are directed to a building which is where the captains sell tickets for their boats. You go in. There are three captains there: a woman dwarf, a man half elf, and a man tiefling. The latter two are rather attractive men.

Nyx asks you which you want to talk to. she'll try talking to another one so you guys can get the best deal. Who do you talk to?