Everything Went Dark
You are correct. Here's what happened:
Evie had realized that since they were in a killing game, her friends would end up dying sometime soon. She wanted to give them mercy, y'know? She wanted to get rid of their anxiety. Jack wasn't in the kitchen yet, so Evie took the pot without anyone seeing. She snuck up behind Emma and smashed her head in. Evie hated doing that. She didn't really want to kill her friends, but she had to, in order to save them of course. Evie knew that Tatum would be asleep and strangled her. Evie felt really guilty. As she left Tatum's dorm, she failed to notice Jennan, who was freaking out. She believed that she had killed Emma, not Evie. Evie sat in the dining hall and forced herself to eat a muffin. Jack joined her with his own breakfast, he didn't notice how weird she was acting.
Evie had realized that since they were in a killing game, her friends would end up dying sometime soon. She wanted to give them mercy, y'know? She wanted to get rid of their anxiety. Jack wasn't in the kitchen yet, so Evie took the pot without anyone seeing. She snuck up behind Emma and smashed her head in. Evie hated doing that. She didn't really want to kill her friends, but she had to, in order to save them of course. Evie knew that Tatum would be asleep and strangled her. Evie felt really guilty. As she left Tatum's dorm, she failed to notice Jennan, who was freaking out. She believed that she had killed Emma, not Evie. Evie sat in the dining hall and forced herself to eat a muffin. Jack joined her with his own breakfast, he didn't notice how weird she was acting.