The Quest of Isaac O'Connor [Unfinished]

Spirit 1 says, "It wasn't me, but I swore I heard someone move next to me before the spirit screamed."

Spirit 2 says, "I don't know who it was! Frankly, anyone could have sliced that spirit in half."

Spirit 3 says, "I'm not sure how you'll figure out who the spirits are that killed my friend, but they can't get away with it!"

Spirit 4 says, "I bet the attack was random. Nobody here can see in the dark, so the murderer wouldn't know who they were killing."

Spirit 5 says, "I'm not the murderer! I'm an honest spirit! But I'm worried that either Spirit 1 or Spirit 2 is lying."

How many spirits are responsible for the murder?

You have 5 choices: