Troubled Waters
With three ships gone, only one of which actually carrying food supplies, you now have many less people to feed. This allows you to help stretch out your rations for long enough to get to Newfoundland. Sadly, the ship carrying livestock and european plants went under, as well as two with building supplies, but the rest of your ships have arrived relatively unharmed. The settlers that you brought from England complain about the trip, but are relieved to have gotten to the colony safely. You have succeeded in your expedition!