His Little Secret

"You can't tell anyone!" You exclaim. "Please..."

"I don't care about him, but I wouldn't want to hurt you. So I'm not gonna tell anyone..." Scott shrugs lightly. You feel relieved, but it only lasts for a short time as he continues talking. "I'm not gonna tell anyone if you stop seeing him..." He rests his hand on yours, tightening his grip when you try to pull away. "You should be with me. Maybe you can't see it now, but I know we would be good together"

You are not sure what scares you the most, the thought of everyone finding out or giving in to Scott's demands. Either way, it seems like you will be losing Brody. You think if you say no to Scott, and everyone finds out, then Brody will be mad at you. And everything you had together with Brody will be destroyed. On the other hand, if you comply with Scott, at least you can save Brody's reputation...