The Spartans
Comments & Ratings
Author | Rating | Date | Comment |
---|---|---|---|
Leftytwo |
Sep 11, 2015 | Really good story, no loose ends and readable grammar (not perfect, but hey, compared to some other stories this ones OK). I like the plot too. | |
Thickskullman |
Jun 28, 2013 | ||
silentninja |
May 3, 2010 | Reminds me of 300! | |
urnam0 |
Mar 21, 2009 | Eight for a nice little story. There wasn't really any clues or reason why some actions resulted in death so I would like to see that corrected | |
Bigbadmonkey |
Feb 6, 2009 | THIS IS SPARTA | |
Adamented |
Jun 3, 2008 | 10 this was a very great story! Good job! I hope you keep up the good work! |
|
apotheosis |
Mar 6, 2007 | Here is how I broke it down. Started you off with a 10. -1 Grammar Errors -1 Historical Inaccuracies -1 Tried to make the Spartans seem heterosexual (they were known to promote homosexuality to increase companionship and therefore the will to fight on the battlefield) -1 Slightly cliche'd with that movie coming out and all. +1 Great first effort +1 While I said there are historical inaccuracies you did label this as fantasy so I should give you a point back... And it is an 8. |
|
donteatpoop |
Feb 28, 2007 | I almost gave this a 9. Good story, excellent writing, truly an amazing first effort for the site. I can't wait to see what else springs forth from you. Why didn't I give you a 10? Spelling is off in several places. Why didn't I give you a 9? There is no possible outcome beyond two rooms of reading if the reader does not choose to talk to the girl. While stream lining is sometimes necessary, it should not be as heavy as this. |