Broadway Baby

You and Aladdin quickly and easily escape the guards and you also quickly become best friends and sing an off brand version of friend like me way before the genie comes into the story.
As the story progresses you and Aladdin find your self in the middle of an adventure to a lion head shaped cave where an old crumbly guy asks you to find him a lamp.
so you and Aladdin go into the cave in search for the lamp and both of you find it at the same time
so what do you do