Extend the Story - Add a Room

You get up and slowly cross the room to him. His eyes widen as you near. "what is your name" you ask gently. "Eli" he says quietly. "Eli i'm sorry i thought you were here to harm me, i should've let you explain yourselves" you say. "i forgive you" he whimpers. "i'm so sorry, let me bandage your wound" you say. You help him up and lead him over to the bed and fetch the bandages from the kitchen. Then you kneel beside him and bandage his arm. You turn to find the other men staring at you in amazement. "what?" you ask. "nothing... " they say and advert their eyes.

Ask them why they are so surprised