The Star of Egypt

You tentatively reach over and try to turn on the lamp.

"I'm so disappointed in you, Mrs. Knight." You whip around when you a voice call out to you.

Arthur Hughes is standing in your living room.

Pointing a handgun at your chest.

"I'd rather hoped you could figure out the puzzle on your own," he sneers. "Ah, well. I suppose we can't all be as smart as your father-in-law was."

Before you can respond, he pulls the trigger.

Guess you should have read that poem a little more closely!
End Of Story